Mystery poster

Movies like Mystery

If you liked Mystery (2012), try True Believer, American Murderer, Blindfire or The Shadow Play. Here are 18 movies like Mystery, picked from what fans of it watch next.

  1. 1
    True Believer poster
    True Believer
    1989
    ★ 6.2
  2. 2
    American Murderer poster
    American Murderer
    2022
    ★ 5.9
  3. 3
    Blindfire poster
    Blindfire
    2020
    ★ 6.8
  4. 4
    The Shadow Play poster
    The Shadow Play
    2019
    ★ 6.7
  5. 5
    Panic poster
    Panic
    2000
    ★ 6.2
  6. 6
    The Public Eye poster
    The Public Eye
    1992
    ★ 6.2
  7. 7
    Tyler Perry's Duplicity poster
    Tyler Perry's Duplicity
    2025
    ★ 6.6
  8. 8
    Òlòtūré poster
    Òlòtūré
    2019
    ★ 6.3
  9. 9
    The Wild Goose Lake poster
    The Wild Goose Lake
    2019
    ★ 6.6
  10. 10
    The Most Hated Woman in America poster
    The Most Hated Woman in America
    2017
    ★ 6.1
  11. 11
    Belly poster
    Belly
    1998
    ★ 6.4
  12. 12
    The Bodyguard poster
    The Bodyguard
    2016
    ★ 5.8
  13. 13
    A Sun poster
    A Sun
    2019
    ★ 7.7
  14. 14
    I Am Elizabeth Smart poster
    I Am Elizabeth Smart
    2017
    ★ 6.8
  15. 15
    In Cold Blood poster
    In Cold Blood
    1967
    ★ 7.5
  16. 16
    Run poster
    Run
    1991
    ★ 6
  17. 17
    Mob Town poster
    Mob Town
    2019
    ★ 6.3
  18. 18
    Goodbye South, Goodbye poster
    Goodbye South, Goodbye
    1998

Recommendations from TMDB.