American Murder: The Family Next Door poster

Movies like American Murder: The Family Next Door

If you liked American Murder: The Family Next Door (2020), try My Father, the BTK Killer, Girl in the Picture, Why Did You Kill Me? or A Deadly American Marriage. Here are 18 movies like American Murder: The Family Next Door, picked from what fans of it watch next.

  1. 1
    My Father, the BTK Killer poster
    My Father, the BTK Killer
    2025
    β˜… 6.8
  2. 2
    Girl in the Picture poster
    Girl in the Picture
    2022
    β˜… 7.1
  3. 3
    Why Did You Kill Me? poster
    Why Did You Kill Me?
    2021
    β˜… 5.9
  4. 4
    A Deadly American Marriage poster
    A Deadly American Marriage
    2025
    β˜… 6.5
  5. 5
    The Imposter poster
    The Imposter
    2012
    β˜… 7.3
  6. 6
    Abducted in Plain Sight poster
    Abducted in Plain Sight
    2017
    β˜… 6.6
  7. 7
    Ted Bundy: Mind of a Monster poster
    Ted Bundy: Mind of a Monster
    2019
  8. 8
    Lover, Stalker, Killer poster
    Lover, Stalker, Killer
    2024
    β˜… 6.8
  9. 9
    Evil Influencer: The Jodi Hildebrandt Story poster
    Evil Influencer: The Jodi Hildebrandt Story
    2025
    β˜… 6.2
  10. 10
    Long Shot poster
    Long Shot
    2017
    β˜… 7.2
  11. 11
    Maternal Instinct poster
    Maternal Instinct
    2026
    β˜… 7.2
  12. 12
    The Menendez Brothers poster
    The Menendez Brothers
    2024
    β˜… 7.2
  13. 13
    A Toxic Love Story poster
    A Toxic Love Story
    2026
    β˜… 6.5
  14. 14
    Out of Thin Air poster
    Out of Thin Air
    2017
    β˜… 5.9
  15. 15
    Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart poster
    Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart
    2026
    β˜… 7.3
  16. 16
    Capturing the Friedmans poster
    Capturing the Friedmans
    2003
    β˜… 7.1
  17. 17
    The Perfect Neighbor poster
    The Perfect Neighbor
    2025
    β˜… 6.8
  18. 18
    Oklahoma City Bombing: American Terror poster
    Oklahoma City Bombing: American Terror
    2025
    β˜… 6.8

Recommendations from TMDB.