Shows like America's Most Wanted
If you liked America's Most Wanted (1988), try Worst Neighbor Ever, Inside the World's Toughest Prisons, Trust Me: The False Prophet or Dateline. Here are 18 shows like America's Most Wanted, picked from what fans of it watch next.
- 1
Worst Neighbor Ever2026 - 2
Inside the World's Toughest Prisons2016★ 7 - 3
Trust Me: The False Prophet2026 - 4
Dateline1992★ 6.6 - 5
Death of the Pastor's Wife2026★ 7.3 - 6
Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes2022★ 7.8 - 7
Fear Thy Neighbor2014 - 8
People Magazine Investigates2016 - 9
The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare2026 - 10
Snapped2004 - 11
Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda2011 - 12
Amy Bradley Is Missing2025★ 6.9 - 13
American Monster2016 - 14
The Murders at Starved Rock2021 - 15
Cold Justice2013 - 16
See No Evil2015 - 17
Deadly Women2005 - 18
Killer Sally2022★ 6.7
Recommendations from TMDB.